{has_more=true, offset=30, total=92, results=[{comment_text=I should have read the reviews before I made this. I only came here afterwards to see if anyone else had horribly hard caramel. Luckily I used store-bought sweet shortcrust pastry for the base so I had no issue there. Lesson learned. Read the comments first!, approved=true, user_name=Em, hs_createdate=1702249881730, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175479822}, {comment_text=I made this recipe before reading reviews. So disappointed with result. The result was really hard caramel and horribly crumbly base. Throw this recipe away., approved=true, user_name=Sarah, hs_createdate=1702249880096, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175598862}, {comment_text=The flavour was good (though very sweet), but the main issue was the caramel went really hard and chewy which made the overall texture a bit unpleasant. I'm not sure if the 8mins of boiling it is overdoing it a bit? I would try again but make a few adjustments (reduce timing of boiling caramel, and more butter in the base as it was quite a small amount for that much biscuit), approved=true, user_name=Mel, hs_createdate=1702249879979, rating_new__1_5_=2, id=11175401011}, {comment_text=yum, approved=true, user_name=jack.c, hs_createdate=1702249879500, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175546157}, {comment_text=Not a fan, its just didn't work. the base was soft, and the caramel was to hard and chewy. Also the heat needs to be on medium to not burn the caramel., approved=true, user_name=Marissa, hs_createdate=1702249878825, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175427097}, {comment_text=Of all the recipes I chose this one because it came from Chelsea, a trusted brand. Broke my own rule that you dont try a new recipe on guests but how hard could it be? Just a simple banoffie pie? It was awful, the caramel set like toffee inspite of my cooking it for only 5 minutes and the base was very crumbly. Lucky my guests were old chums and they didnt care. I later reread the recipe and noticed Chelsea have written that they haven't actually tested this recipe!, approved=true, user_name=Katie, hs_createdate=1702249878696, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175343156}, {comment_text=The instructions for the cameral are incorrect - 8 minutes is too long as the caramel starts to split after 4., approved=true, user_name=Carol, hs_createdate=1702249878049, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175405444}, {comment_text=Simple..Quick..Easy..and Deliciously Delectable!!!, approved=true, user_name=Angela, hs_createdate=1702249877994, rating_new__1_5_=5, id=11175546133}, {comment_text=Not a big fan. I think the method needs more instructions - it's just too vague. Needs to be measured instructions. Due to that I think results will be too skewed and varied. Found the caramel too sweet and too much., approved=true, user_name=Rach, hs_createdate=1702249877659, rating_new__1_5_=2, id=11175343141}, {comment_text=My caramel tasted very grainy. What did I do wrong.CHELSEA: Hi there, sorry to hear that! Grainy caramel can be a result of undercooking or overcooking the caramel, or sugar crystallisation. For the latter, brushing the sides of the pot with a wet pastry brush during cooking can help to prevent this., approved=true, user_name=sue, hs_createdate=1702249876688, rating_new__1_5_=1, id=11175572881}]}
Reviews
92
What did you think of this recipe?
Em
I should have read the reviews before I made this. I only came here afterwards to see if anyone else had horribly hard caramel. Luckily I used store-bought sweet shortcrust pastry for the base so I had no issue there. Lesson learned. Read the comments first!
1
Sarah
I made this recipe before reading reviews. So disappointed with result. The result was really hard caramel and horribly crumbly base. Throw this recipe away.
1
Mel
The flavour was good (though very sweet), but the main issue was the caramel went really hard and chewy which made the overall texture a bit unpleasant. I'm not sure if the 8mins of boiling it is overdoing it a bit? I would try again but make a few adjustments (reduce timing of boiling caramel, and more butter in the base as it was quite a small amount for that much biscuit)
2
jack.c
yum
5
Marissa
Not a fan, its just didn't work. the base was soft, and the caramel was to hard and chewy. Also the heat needs to be on medium to not burn the caramel.
1
Katie
Of all the recipes I chose this one because it came from Chelsea, a trusted brand. Broke my own rule that you dont try a new recipe on guests but how hard could it be? Just a simple banoffie pie? It was awful, the caramel set like toffee inspite of my cooking it for only 5 minutes and the base was very crumbly. Lucky my guests were old chums and they didnt care. I later reread the recipe and noticed Chelsea have written that they haven't actually tested this recipe!
1
Carol
The instructions for the cameral are incorrect - 8 minutes is too long as the caramel starts to split after 4.
Not a big fan. I think the method needs more instructions - it's just too vague. Needs to be measured instructions. Due to that I think results will be too skewed and varied. Found the caramel too sweet and too much.
2
sue
My caramel tasted very grainy. What did I do wrong.CHELSEA: Hi there, sorry to hear that! Grainy caramel can be a result of undercooking or overcooking the caramel, or sugar crystallisation. For the latter, brushing the sides of the pot with a wet pastry brush during cooking can help to prevent this.
Base Crush the malt biscuits to fine crumbs. Add the melted butter and mix well. Press the biscuit mixture onto the base and up the sides of the tin. Place in the freezer to set.
Filling Place the Chelsea Soft Brown Sugar and butter in a heavy-based saucepan. Cook over medium heat until the sugar has dissolved and butter melted.
Add the condensed milk and bring to a boil, stirring constantly. Reduce heat and simmer for 3 minutes, stirring, until mixture is more golden in colour and smells like caramel. Be careful not to overcook it, or caramel will be chewy. Remove from heat and stir in vanilla.
Pour onto the chilled biscuit base and place in the fridge to cool.
Topping When the caramel has set, whip the cream to soft peaks. Top the caramel with sliced banana and spoon whipped cream over the top. Use a vegetable peeler to grate chocolate shavings over the top of the pie. Serve, or refrigerate until ready to serve.
Leftovers keep well in the fridge for a couple of days (bananas will brown a little over time).
I should have read the reviews before I made this. I only came here afterwards to see if anyone else had horribly hard caramel. Luckily I used store-bought sweet shortcrust pastry for the base so I had no issue there. Lesson learned. Read the comments first!
1
Sarah
I made this recipe before reading reviews. So disappointed with result. The result was really hard caramel and horribly crumbly base. Throw this recipe away.
1
Mel
The flavour was good (though very sweet), but the main issue was the caramel went really hard and chewy which made the overall texture a bit unpleasant. I'm not sure if the 8mins of boiling it is overdoing it a bit? I would try again but make a few adjustments (reduce timing of boiling caramel, and more butter in the base as it was quite a small amount for that much biscuit)
2
jack.c
yum
5
Marissa
Not a fan, its just didn't work. the base was soft, and the caramel was to hard and chewy. Also the heat needs to be on medium to not burn the caramel.
1
Katie
Of all the recipes I chose this one because it came from Chelsea, a trusted brand. Broke my own rule that you dont try a new recipe on guests but how hard could it be? Just a simple banoffie pie? It was awful, the caramel set like toffee inspite of my cooking it for only 5 minutes and the base was very crumbly. Lucky my guests were old chums and they didnt care. I later reread the recipe and noticed Chelsea have written that they haven't actually tested this recipe!
1
Carol
The instructions for the cameral are incorrect - 8 minutes is too long as the caramel starts to split after 4.
Not a big fan. I think the method needs more instructions - it's just too vague. Needs to be measured instructions. Due to that I think results will be too skewed and varied. Found the caramel too sweet and too much.
2
sue
My caramel tasted very grainy. What did I do wrong.CHELSEA: Hi there, sorry to hear that! Grainy caramel can be a result of undercooking or overcooking the caramel, or sugar crystallisation. For the latter, brushing the sides of the pot with a wet pastry brush during cooking can help to prevent this.